| | Strangers on a Train | 7.6 | 1951 |
| | Singin' in the Rain | 7.4 | 1952 |
| | Bad and the Beautiful, The | 6.9 | 1952 |
| | Jeux Interdits | 7.4 | 1952 |
| | 5 Fingers | 7.2 | 1952 |
| | Quiet Man, The | 6.1 | 1952 |
| | Viva Zapata! | 6.5 | 1952 |
| | Come Back, Little Sheba | 7.4 | 1952 |
| | Ikiru | 7.7 | 1952 |
| | High Noon | 7.3 | 1952 |
| | Greatest Show on Earth, The | 6.6 | 1952 |
| | Band Wagon, The | 7 | 1953 |
| | From Here to Eternity | 7.1 | 1953 |
| | Robe, The | 6.4 | 1953 |
| | Shane | 7.1 | 1953 |
| | Peter Pan | 6.6 | 1953 |
| | Stalag 17 | 7.3 | 1953 |
| | Lili | 6.6 | 1953 |
| | Big Heat, The | 7.5 | 1953 |
| | Roman Holiday | 7.4 | 1953 |
| | Titanic | 6.5 | 1953 |
| | Star Is Born, A | 6.6 | 1954 |
| | Caine Mutiny, The | 6.8 | 1954 |
| | Barefoot Contessa, The | 6.2 | 1954 |
| | Country Girl, The | 6.3 | 1954 |